Malena Amusa
Has Geico Gone too Far?
“Using Geico.com is so easy, a caveman could do it!” is the tag line for Geico’s insurance commercials that have cavemen respond sensitively to the notion that they are dumb, simple creatures.
Some say these commercials are allegories for some communities of color. Take a look below, you be the judge.
Blogger, Angry Black Woman, thinks Geico is making a mockery of Black people’s struggle to counter-act historical stereotypes about their intelligence.
In the world of the commercials, the cavemen are mostly well-educated, cosmopolitan people–no, no, Men, because we have yet to see a female cave person–who hold jobs and have plenty of money and seem middle or upper class. When they hear the line about ’so easy a caveman could do it’ (or see posters about it) they become offended because the commercial insinuates that they are nothing but stupid, bipedal animals only capable of the simplest of tasks. No matter how they try to address this issue - by talking directly to Geico, by appearing on Bill O’Reilly-type cable news channel shows, or even by going to therapy - the message they get from everyone is that the commercials are valid because, well, cavemen are just simple, stupid bipeds barely above animals. There’s even a commercial where one caveman is disappointed in another caveman for ’selling out’ by getting insurance through Geico.If this isn’t clear to everyone by now, I think the Cavemen are really thinly veiled pastiches of black people! Their skin is even dark (but not too dark or else someone might get offended). They’re seen as simple, stupid creatures. They have a hard time getting white people to understand their feelings about the issue. In the end, the prevailing opinion is that the slogan is fair because the cavemen really are what others think they are, despite the evidence. And, let’s not forget, that the cavemen are really just being oversensitive to begin with.
If anyone out there doesn’t get how this is exactly the struggle black folks have been having with the white-dominated media since… well, since minstrel shows, let me know. I will school you.
What do you think?
Posted at 10:12 AM, Apr 05, 2007 in Media Analysis | Permalink | View Comments
Comments
If anything, I think they're making fun of metrosexuals. But they certainly do speak to the way that many people of color (not just black people) react to stereotypes.
Posted by: Malik | April 5, 2007 12:28 PM
I'm unsure if I agree with Angry Black Woman's connection between Geico's cavemen and people of color. I definitely differ with her opinion that the cavemen are stupid. I think the cavemen come off as intelligent and sensitive, not brutish and dumb. The non-cavepeople seem to be the ignorant ones. This is irony is what is supposed to make the commercial funny.
Posted by: john | April 5, 2007 1:03 PM
I agree with both Malik and John.
I think what is more concerning is how the media deals with difference and how it finds that exploiting highly racialized scenarios through mockery and comedy are formulas for commercial success.
Remember: http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/blackhistory/news/story?id=1983393
Posted by: malena | April 6, 2007 8:11 AM
John, I think you may ave missed my point. I said that, in the world of the commercials, the in-ad geico commercials depict the cavemen as brutish and dumb. I wasn't agreeing with that assessment. Clearly the cavemen are not brutish or dumb. That's one of the points.
While I understand that the irony of the commercials make some people laugh, having been on the receiving end of people who *act exactly like the non-cavemen* in the commercials, I don't feel like laughing.
Posted by: the angry black woman | April 6, 2007 7:37 PM
I agree ABW. Too many times I've been made to feel like the cavemen with people assuming i'm not on their level. one time while reporting in south africa, i took a trip to swaziland. a white man walked up to me in a gift shop and said: "can you tell your boss i said hello." i was clearly not an employee, not there there's anything wrong with that. but in places like this where whites are used to seeing blacks in only subservient positions, the idea never crossed this man's mind that i too could be in the gift shop as a tourist, looking for gifts!
Posted by: malena | April 9, 2007 11:05 AM
Thanks "Angry Black Woman" for now comparing Black people to cavemen. ABW, do you even realize what you're saying?
Posted by: Jessica | April 9, 2007 5:29 PM
i have to say ABW needs to stop projecting how she feels about her community and its response to racism to the rest of the world....
i kinda understand that this commercial is sort of a parody of how minorities react to stereotypes and it is offensive, but i must say Geico doesn't need to apologize cuz they're just being insensitive/condescending (maybe w/out even realizing it) and if all condescending pricks were made to apologize we'd be hearing apologies 24/7 in the media.
Posted by: sarah | April 10, 2007 10:19 AM
Malena - That story makes me sad, but doesn't at all surprise me.
Jessica - Wow, you really just don't grok my point at all. I'm not comparing black people to the Cavemen from your 3rd grade education of what Cavemen are. I'm simply saying that I think the Geico cavemen are meant to represent minorities. A decision that the advertising company made, not me.
Sarah - 1) I never asked for Geico to apologize. You must be thinking of someone else. 2) How exactly am I 'projecting'? I don't think that word means what you think it means. 3) If all condescending pricks were made to apologize, people might think twice about being pricks and the world would be a better place. Not holding people accountable for their flaws only leads to more flaws.
Posted by: the angry black woman | April 17, 2007 5:52 AM
Malena - Interesting how you can know what has crossed that man's mind. I guess there is no possible way that it was an honest mistake. If a black male asked you that same question I'm sure you would have taken it as a mistake. What is actually racist is that you assume because he was white that he looked down at you. You make assumptions because of color. Shame on you.
Posted by: Dan | April 19, 2007 3:29 PM
ABW is correct, I always thought these were funny, and it took a while but it slowly dawned on me that these commercials are parodying a group of people dealing with untrue, insulting sterotypes. It's pretty clear it's black people. (Take the episode at the party, with the whole "sold out" dynamic.)
But there's also something harmless about it. As you say it's sympathetic to the cavemen, harsh on the prejudiced folks. You could say by parodying the whole dynamic, it is belittling the whole concept of prejudice, but I choose not to look at it that way. Instead, I think the fact that we laugh so easily at the people who are so wrong about these cavemen shows how far we've come: their views are so outdated its funny.
Posted by: Chris | April 23, 2007 6:47 PM
You guy's have missed the whole point...
The very concept of "evolution" (from RNA, TO DNA, SCALES TO FEATHERS, APES TO MAN) is a racist concept...
The fact is, most people believe our ancestors we're "sub-human"...
I think these commercials show that quite well...
Posted by: Robben | May 4, 2007 9:43 PM