Guest Columnist
An Activist-Bride’s Vow for Racial Justice
by Samantha Erskine
I am a huge fan of WeddingBee, a website community for those excited about weddings (Yes, I’m planning my wedding!). But, as a bride-to-be who is committed to social justice, not only in my profession but also in planning my nuptials (for example, in looking for a venue, I refused to consider anything that had the word “colonial” or “plantation” in the title), I could not believe that the owners of my favorite wedding blog have sold their site to eHarmony. eHarmony is the same dating site that refuses to match same-sex couples and acknowledges that it routinely rejects “certain types of people.” Therefore, plenty of people of color have been denied opportunities to find love.
Discrimination against the LGBTQ community goes directly against what I stand for. For one, the same arguments against same-sex marriage were used to ban interracial marriage. Also, people of color comprise a substantial chunk of the LGBTQ community, and the LGBTQ rights movement is rooted in the struggle for racial equality. In addition, many queer families of color have been subject to attacks based on government-mandated policies, which have perpetuated racism and racial disparities. Moreover, opponents of racial justice and same-sex marriage target both movements and stigmatize what really are basic human rights.
In addition, eHarmony's founder Neil Clark Warren, an evangelical Christian, is strongly connected to Focus on the Family, an organization that believes that feminism is harmful to women. As a woman of color, I have been empowered by the principles of feminism: freedom, equality, the belief that women's identities, bodies and family choices are matters of personal determination, not of public debate. The LGBTQ movement is my natural ally and it shares my principles of justice.
As an activist bride, I believe in marriage equality, but aside from a few episodes of Bridezillas and Whose Wedding Is It Anyway?, the wedding industry, in general (like most of America), is resistant to the idea of same-sex couples in wedding magazines and mainstream wedding websites. Weddingbee was different and embraced queer brides-to-be.
So, now I'm at a quandary. Do I continue to support Weddingbee (helping eHarmony make money AND effectively demonstrating tacit approval of eHarmony's discriminatory practices)? Or, do I put aside my activism and social justice principles and just focus on developing beautiful wedding ideas? Several of Weddingbee's queer bloggers have quit in protest of the sale. Other queer bloggers will continue to be featured on Weddingbee, though, and I am sure that this business tactic is a mere facade of acceptance of same-sex marriage.
What do you all think?
Posted at 1:30 PM, Oct 03, 2008 in LGBT | Permalink | View Comments
Comments
sigh... so sorry to hear about the eHarmony buy out.
Another resource i follow, as it does speak to queer weddings and alternative, low cost, creative ideas is Off Beat Bride (see http://offbeatbride.com/2008/09/transgender-groom). And another sigh... there is a stark lack of racial diversity on the site.
good luck with your wedding!
Posted by: jodie | October 4, 2008 11:52 AM
There are plenty of sites that you can use to get excited about your wedding that aren't associated with such F***ed up ideologies. Try indiebride - I liked that one. Or just keep looking.
Posted by: fran | October 4, 2008 4:20 PM
I think that this is life. As our society becomes more interconnected and as the economy fails we find ourselves having to set aside principals that we thought were ingrained and unwavering. Example, when you swore you would never shop at Walmart because they don't pay their workers enough for the long hard hours they work and that they drive people away from the small business owners in a town and effectively kill it, but you don't have a job and the student loan people come back every month along with the landlord, you find your self wondering if maybe you could buy some basic personal things there but shop for your food at the Whole Foods (just to balance the scales).
However, I do think that in your case the website made an financial choice (I assume that eHarmony paid WeddingBee a ton of money to get their site) and a choice they knew might affect their subscribers. I wont tell you what to do, but if you love the site and can learn to live with the fact that eHarmony is running it, than stay. But if you know that you can find another wedding blog site and still maintain your principals, than change or get the LGTB community to start its own blog site for Activist Brides like yourself.
Hope the wedding planing itself is going well. Miss much, love more. Lisa
Posted by: Lisa | October 5, 2008 9:55 AM
Thanks for this thoughtful post, ActivistBride. You really sum up so much of what I've been thinking about since I first heard about the sale weeks ago. Honestly, out of principal I should not continue to blog for such a site. Heck, even one year ago I would have left immediately upon hearing the news and had my content pulled. I think that for me, in this this election year especially, I am staying for now because it is so necessary for as many people as possible to be informed about the issues pertinent to our (POC/ QPOC/ LGBTQ) communities. Is it selling out on my part? Probably. But for all the talk of people standing up to their principles and leaving, I have to ask- where were they before? Being an ally to the LGBTQ community is much more than silently nodding when Gingerbread and I (the token queer bloggers) writes about these issues. I felt that I couldn't leave knowing these issues would never be addressed with one month to go (bah, don't get me started on my beef with electoral politics, but whatever.) My point is, do what you gotta do to stay sane. For now, staying is what I gotta do.
Posted by: Sweet Tea | October 7, 2008 9:30 AM
Thanks for the well wishes and wedding blog referrals! There is actually another blog that I like called Style Me Pretty, which I haven't been on much, since the day that I discovered Weddingbee. And, if all else fails, I guess there is always theknot.com! My major issue with Weddingbee, and corporations in general, is that most of them could care less about being socially conscious. I know it's idealistic of me to think that corporations will do right by society. I'm sure eHarmony paid Weddingbee a whole lot of money, which (especially during this economic crisis) really comes in handy. I just wish Weddingbee were more picky about who they sold the blog too. I really hate having to put aside my principles just to enjoy the things that make me smile. The less activist-minded people don't think twice about things like this.
Posted by: Samantha | October 7, 2008 12:17 PM
Hi Miss Sweet Tea!
I sent my last comment before seeing your comment (there is a delay in posting the comments). I'm happy to see that you read RaceWire.
I totally feel you. People w/social justice principles should stay on Weddingbee and have their "non-traditional" perspectives heard/read/seen. I think that by you and Mrs. Gingerbread staying on, you are educating a whole lot of ignorant people. And maybe one day (I pray - soon!), the world will be more open to all of our issues. Heck, I'm still waiting for an Afro-Diasporic blogger to join the Hive. I know there was 1 but she was verrrrry light-skinned and she didn't really write much from a POC perspective. So, there is a lot of progress to be made on Weddingbee.
Good luck and best wishes on your upcoming December wedding!
Posted by: Samantha/ActivistBride | October 7, 2008 7:35 PM
Samantha,
After posting my comment I went over to OffBeat Bride and dropped the writer a note to mention the lack of diversity on the site. I received an immediate response and there is a new post today inviting a dialog in response to my note. http://offbeatbride.com/2008/10/offbeat-bride-diversity
Best, j
Posted by: jodie | October 8, 2008 4:32 PM
Being a bride is a happiest moment in woman’s life. However, confusion and overwhelmed excitement can result to a negative feelings and emotions. Most of us rely on financial assistance for survival. We know that borrowings are part of economic flow. Americans now have new hope for a change. They are waiting for it to happen for them to recover from the said situation. Strategic plans are of great importance in solving the economic problem. Marriage is a social institution, especially here in the US. However, the divorce rate is just over 50%, and the most common reason is over money. Maybe some of these couples should have gotten payday installment loans, or some counseling. Finances are oft the most common reason, not clashing over children, not abuse or infidelity, but over money. Perhaps it would beneficial if as soon as a marriage license is granted, the couples are shipped off to a mandatory money management course for a weekend. One of the keys to marriage, and indeed any relationship, is compromise, and equally important are the concepts of teamwork and also of communication. You have to be able to work with your partner, meet on common ground, be able to tell them everything, and be able to relay what you are thinking or feeling. Communication is good for both of you. This is especially true about your financial situation. Communication, especially about finances, is paramount to proper money management for couples. Had so many other people listened to this, they may not have had to go to divorce court. Now, no one ever said it is or was ever going to be easy; you will have your ups and downs. Just remember that if you hit a snag in your family’s budget, payday installment loans may be the trick to saving your budget. Possibly even your marriage. Click to read more on Payday Installment Loans.
Posted by: Lisa P | November 25, 2008 2:24 AM